Florida Georgia Line’s Tyler Hubbard thought he was getting the surprise of a lifetime on Sunday (yes, April 1) when his wife, Hayley, shared with him that she was pregnant. She even captured his reaction on camera.

Clearly in shock and laughing nervously, Hubbard shares the big news with the couple’s 3-month-old daughter, Olivia. “Liv, we have some big news this morning,” the singer says, cradling his newborn in bed on Easter morning. “Are you ready to have a little brother or sister?”

He’s surprised, to say the least, but tries to see the silver lining of having two babies at once. “Oh no, Liv! We get some good practice for the next nine months and be ready to pop another one out,” he tells her.